When to Burn the Playbook and Start Over (And When Not To)

There’s a moment in almost every business when someone looks around and says, "Wait. Why are we doing it this way?"

Sometimes, that question leads to clarity.

Other times, it leads to chaos. Oops.

Because while it’s tempting to scrap everything and start fresh, not every situation calls for a total reboot.

So how do you know when to burn the playbook—and when to just make a few solid edits?

Let’s talk about it.

Start Over When:

1. The Strategy No Longer Matches the Reality

If the market has changed, your customers have changed, your business model has changed, but you’re still using the same go-to-market plan you made three years ago? That’s a mismatch.

Sticking with a plan that no longer fits isn’t loyalty. It’s inertia. If your strategy can’t answer the current moment, it’s time to scrap it and build one that can.

This isn’t just about surface-level pivots. It’s about asking big-picture questions: Who are we serving now? What do they need? What’s changed in how we deliver it? If your answers don’t align with the systems you’re using, you’re trying to run a modern company with an outdated blueprint.

2. Everyone’s Following the Process, But Nothing’s Working

Sometimes the issue isn’t effort, it’s direction. If your team is executing flawlessly and still missing the mark, you don’t have a performance problem. You have a strategy problem.

This one’s tricky because it can look like success from the outside. Work is getting done. Boxes are being checked. But results? Not so much.

That’s your cue to stop optimizing the old system and start designing a new one. Don’t just work harder. Work differently. A broken strategy executed perfectly is still a broken strategy.

It’s time to zoom out, ask better questions, and figure out where your outcomes and your actions started to drift apart.

3. You’re Building a New Culture, Not Just a New Plan

If you’re trying to fundamentally shift how your team operates—say, moving from reactive to proactive, or from siloed to cross-functional—you may need a full reset.

Culture shifts don’t happen with tweaks. They happen with intention, alignment, and yes, sometimes starting over. Because culture lives in the HOW. If the "how" still reflects the old world, no amount of messaging will create lasting change.

This is especially true if the old system is soaked in mistrust, confusion, or fear. You can’t build psychological safety on top of a foundation that taught people to be guarded. Sometimes you have to start clean. Name what didn’t work. Name what you’re building now. And do it differently, from the ground up.

Don’t Burn It Down If:

1. The Problem Is Execution, Not Strategy

A good plan executed poorly will always look like a bad plan. Before you toss it, ask: Are people actually following it? Is it clear? Has it been given a fair shot?

If the strategy is sound but the rollout is chaotic, you probably need better enablement, not a bonfire.

2. You’re Just Bored

Innovation is great. But sometimes what feels like stagnation is just the natural rhythm of growth. Don’t confuse your own desire for novelty with a need to reinvent the wheel.

Check in with your team. Look at the data. Ask what’s working. Don’t burn the playbook just because you’re antsy.

3. You Don’t Have a Better Plan Yet

It’s one thing to tear down what’s broken. It’s another to do it without a clue of what to build next.

Pause before you set fire to the old playbook. Get clear on what the new one needs to solve. Bring people into the conversation. And make sure your team has what they need to move forward—not just away from what’s behind them.

The Bottom Line

You don’t need to be precious with a process that isn’t serving you. But you also don’t need to swing the pendulum to chaos every time something feels off.

Burn the playbook when it’s holding you back. Edit the playbook when it just needs a little work.

And if you’re not sure which one you’re dealing with?

That’s what we’re here for.

At The Threadsmith Group, we help teams figure out what to fix, what to keep, and what to toss. If your business needs a reset, let’s find the answer together.

Previous
Previous

WednesdAMA: Reader-Submitted Questions

Next
Next

Why So Many Good Employees Quit (And How to Spot the Warning Signs)